This was Shelf Care Moms Club's second virtual book club pick! We were excited for a cozy mystery, and thought the timing was perfect with the release of the Netflix movie (with a stellar cast BTW). Unfortunately, this just didn't hit the mark for us.

This is a whimsical dreamscape of a book—the world depicted in Water Moon is gorgeous and complex. For how much whimsy and silliness this book had, it also contained so much depth. The conversation on choices and regrets and the ways in which they shape your being was done masterfully.

3.75 stars rounded up. Slight spoliers ahead, so read at your own risk!