We couldn't pick up Book 2 in this completed duology fast enough — both Lib and Em read them both like one story and it was a wonderful adventure. The editing in both books is fantastic — no words or plot lines felt unnecessary. Was it a little bit predictable? Yes. Was it still so enjoyable in how it played out? Definitely.

The first book in what Libby calls "the perfect duology!" — truly a 5 star read for both Em and Lib.

Emily Henry strikes again! We all loooved this book. A book about books?? How could you not?

4.75 Stars! I really enjoyed this book from start to finish—it followed a similar structure to Phantasma (i.e. rounds of games and trials), but definitely still felt unique. And it was chalk full of my favorite tropes: Enemies to lovers, forced proximity, games and trials, he falls first, lost memories and bargains with a devil. 👌

This book seriously came out of nowhere and I AM HERE FOR IT.
Author: Rachel Schneider

4.5 stars! This duology wraps up everything with a perfect little bow. I’m deducting .5 stars for predictability, but I definitely was pleasantly surprised with a few things I did not see coming in this one.

5 stars for a Young Adult novel. I flip flop between 4 and 4.5 stars for me.

Once things really got cooking from a plot perspective, I couldn’t put it down!

This book has the potential to be the start of an amazing series! I just wish I had waited to read it until the rest of the series is out.

First, I am just unashamed to say I am very entertained by this series, despite its flaws. I honestly kept thinking about the last chapter of this one for WEEKS afterward.

Dragons! I'll be honest, this series might be a bit overhyped, but it is the perfect entry to the romantasy genre and is non-stop FUN! I had a hard time putting it down the first time, and started book 2 the same day I finished this.